South Beloit to reconsider fish fertilizer plan after initial rejection

A proposal to transform a property at 930 Elmwood in the heart of South Beloit into an organic fertilizer production site has returned to the city’s doorstep. After a narrow defeat in April by a 2-3 vote, the City Council is set to revisit a Special Use Permit that has pitted industrial innovation against the preservation of local community hubs.

The project, originally presented to the South Beloit Zoning Committee on March 18, 2026 by Kent Roe, seeks a Special Use Permit to operate a soil additive production and wholesale distribution facility at 930 Elmwood Avenue. The operation involves processing approximately one ton of Asian carp, an invasive fish species, using a lactic acid emulsification process to create organic fertilizer for local farmers. Situated in a "Commercial Retail" (CR) zoning district, the facility would directly abut St. Peter Catholic Church and stand only 850 feet from the popular Dari Ripple ice cream shop and 1,500 feet from Nature at the Confluence.

Local property owner Jeanne Nichols, who owns a seven-unit apartment building adjacent to the site, has emerged as a leading voice of opposition. Nichols argues that the facility represents a significant "nuisance" risk, citing concerns over flies and a persistent "fish smell" that could drive down property values and ruin the quality of life for her tenants.

"It's a good place to live; I just don't understand it," Nichols stated about South Beloit and the plan to put fertilizer processing facility so close to residences. In a phone call, Ms. Nichols shared that she did some homework prior to her public comment at the April 6 city council meeting and couldn't find any similar fish fertilizer plants located in a city center within a 100-mile radius. She contends that while the business itself may be valid, the location—surrounded by schools, residents, and churches—is fundamentally inappropriate.

The fertilizer facility was approved by the zoning board and reached the city council chambers on 6 April. Ms. Nichols expressed her opposition to the facility as she thought people were being disingenuous when they said that there was not going to be any odor involved.

Subscribe to the only newsletter focused completely on Rockton, Roscoe, and South Beloit - for free.

Sign up now

After Ms. Nelson's public comment, Samantha Harrison of the South Beloit Zoning Board and Mayor Tom Fitzgerald took time to respond.

Harrison strongly defended the technical aspects of the proposal. She advised the Council that the use of lactic acid makes it "so much easier to control where the smell would be coming from" compared to other industrial sites. She characterized the potential odor as a "sweet fish smell" because the fish are processed fresh, and explicitly stated that the smells coming from Axium (a nearby food ingredient plant) "far supersede" anything this facility would produce.

The Mayor addressed the growing tension, acknowledging that while Council members are open to criticism, they "would not do anything that was detrimental to the City." He noted that a "small group on Facebook" had been highly critical of the decision-making process. Fitzgerald emphasized the rigorous path of the proposal, explaining that the Zoning Board "picks everything that the business owner says apart" to ensure it fits the city’s "business narrative" and code before it ever reaches the Council for final due diligence.

Despite a positive recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission and the Mayor’s defense of the process, the Council voted 3-2 to deny the permit on April 6. Commissioners Adleman, Hedrington, and Morse led the opposition, citing concerns that a "fish smell" would make it hard for residents to sell their houses and would negatively affect property values.

While the Special Use Permit was denied, the legal path forward remains technical. City Attorney Sosnowski advised the Council that they must now identify specific "findings of fact" that were not met to justify the denial legally.

However, the matter is far from settled. The fertilizer facility is officially back on the agenda for tonight’s City Council meeting. Preceding the vote, the city has scheduled a special 30-minute presentation from Adam ElBrichi regarding the technical production of soil additives at the Elmwood property. This move suggests the developer may be attempting to provide new evidence to sway the "nay" voters and secure the permit for the controversial site.